March 22, 2024 17:12:36 Ningbo Consumer Protection Commission
High tech or IQ tax? Let's take a look at the evaluation results of the sleep monitor by the Ningbo Municipal Consumer Protection Commission
In recent years, with the accelerated pace of work and life, the number of people experiencing sleep problems has been on the rise, and the group of "sleep disorders" is gradually becoming younger.
To meet market demand, many businesses have launched sleep aid products. Is the popular sleep monitor high-tech or an "intelligence tax"?
In May 2023, the Ningbo Consumer Protection Commission, in collaboration with the Yinzhou District Consumer Protection Commission, launched a 10 month comparative experiment on 10 mainstream brand sleep monitors on the market, including safety tests and user experience evaluations. The relevant results were released on the eve of this year's International Sleep Day.
picture
The comparative test results show that all 10 sleep monitor samples meet the national standard requirements in safety indicators such as electromagnetic radiation testing.
User experience evaluation
picture
(1. "★" in the table represents satisfaction, "☆" represents the satisfaction score of half a "★"; 2 All 10 samples were entrusted to Ningbo Customs Technical Center for safety indicator testing; 3. This comparative experiment is only responsible for the samples
Product features and functions
From the perspective of working principle, seven sleep machines, including Xinnuo, Siyoujia, Yimaituo, Deep Dolphin, Left Point, Bonchen, and Sleepy Bear, all use transcranial microcurrent stimulation (CES) therapy, which stimulates the brain with low intensity microcurrent to improve abnormal brain waves, regulate the secretion of neurotransmitters and stress hormones in the brain, and thus achieve the goal of treating insomnia. Except for products that use CES technology, Homerion and Hyundai are handheld micro current conducting products that are relatively cheaper and easier to operate.
In addition, daily necessities have also been developed into sleep aid products, such as the Yaner Sleep Embracing Headband, which is labeled as "sleep aid" by installing a head vibration massage function.
From the perspective of appearance design, the Deep Dolphin, Xinnuo, and Homerion are made of metal bodies, and the user feedback is that the touch is comfortable and smooth, with a strong sense of technology in the design.
From the perspective of operation, the experience feedback shows that the Homerion and Hyundai handheld sleep monitors are the most convenient to use, small in size, and easy to carry around. The transcranial microcurrent sleep monitor commonly uses ear clip type and requires specialized conductive fluid, making the operation relatively cumbersome.
From the perspective of user experience, Xinnuo and Left Point have received high praise from users. The ear clip gasket design is reasonable, and the conductive liquid is skin friendly, making it the most comfortable. And the products of three brands, including Siyoujia, Bonchen, and Sleepy Bear, have a slight tingling sensation. Yanai's sleeping headscarf has a loud vibration noise.
From the perspective of usage effectiveness, Xinnuo and Bonchen have the highest scores, and users generally give feedback that the effect is good.
From the perspective of featured services, Xinnuo and Shendolphin support Bluetooth connection to mobile apps for interaction.
Regarding this result, the Ningbo Municipal Consumer Protection Commission kindly reminds:
1、 A legitimate sleep therapy device should have a medical device product registration certificate. When purchasing, it is advisable to choose sleep aid products that have medical device product registration certification and a complete after-sales service system, and pay attention to keeping the purchase certificate.
2、 Transcranial microcurrent stimulation therapy is generally used in hospitals to treat mental illnesses such as depression, including alleviating insomnia caused by mental illness. When choosing sleep aid products, it is important to fully understand whether the products are suitable for oneself.
3、 At present, many sleep aid products lack industry standards and specifications. The higher the price of the product, the better the quality of the product. The higher the price, the more necessary consumer rationality should be maintained. The best way to prevent insomnia is to develop good sleep habits. If insomnia is severe, it is necessary to go to a regular hospital for treatment in a timely manner.
4、 If there is any physical discomfort or objection to the product during use, relevant testing institutions can be commissioned to test the product. If it is confirmed that there is a problem with the product quality, complaints can be made to relevant departments to protect the rights and interests of consumers in accordance with the law.