DeepSeek、 Bean buns WPS AI， Who is the strongest AI paper artifact?

DeepSeek、 Bean buns WPS AI， Who is the strongest AI paper artifact?

Wisdom and

follow with interest

2025-03-27

1 Comment

908 views

1 Collection

13 minutes

  B-end product managers need to conduct more in-depth user interviews, research, and analysis, while C-end product managers need more rapid user testing, feedback, and iteration

Faced with a mountain of paper tasks, how to efficiently utilize AI tools to improve writing efficiency while ensuring paper quality is a concern for many students and researchers. This article will comprehensively compare and test three popular AI paper support tools - DeepSeek, Doubao, and WPS AI, from topic selection, framework construction, content generation, format adjustment to final plagiarism detection and PPT production, to explore who is the true "AI paper tool".

As a student majoring in management, I have to check the To do list every day and find that I have to write a small paper for all three water courses this week. My anxious heart is completely dead.

Try AI and see if it can handle it quickly?

Choose a topic and outline, I am stronger than AI

The first and most difficult step is to choose a topic.

The topic selection for empirical papers in management is nothing more than the arrangement and combination of several popular concepts such as A, B, C, etc., and then introducing a special point of D to conduct a mechanism analysis.

Taking the international business of a mixed bag of elite professionals as an example, we will assign specific requirements - "related to the XXX field, easily accessible data, strong operability, and innovative" to Dou Bao DeepSeek、Kimi。

To verify the quality of the selected topics, we asked Kimi, Dou Bao, and DeepSeeK to rank the 9 topics based on their requirements as the evaluation criteria.

Kimi's sorting is: 1/9/6/7/4/3/5/8/2;

The sorting of bean buns is: 1/9/6/3/5/2/7/4/8;

The sorting of DeepSeek is: 4/6/3/2/5/7/1/9/8;

According to the ranking of AI, Kimi's topic seems to be superior.

Of course, to prevent AI from monopolizing power and confusing the public, we will send CNKI personnel to verify the reliability of the topic.

How to define B-end products and B-end product manager methodology

Compared to C-end products, the biggest feature of B-end products is that they are aimed at specific domain users and have a much smaller quantity, but they pay more attention to in-depth exploration of user professional domain operation processes - that is, they have stronger professionalism and are more closely integrated with business.

View details>

1/9 (same title) There aren't many people writing about it, but the data is difficult to find; 2/4 is similar, question 2 is a bit too big, which type of enterprise? How to measure the competitiveness of different types of enterprises? How to quantify the innovation of the 4 modes? 3/5 belong to the same category, and the selection of research subjects for 5-3 is more specific; Building trust is difficult to quantify, and data is also hard to find; 7/8 is about to be written poorly.

In summary, AI cannot fabricate an innovative and good topic out of thin air.

Never mind, it's better to choose a more conventional one. We take "the impact of ESG standards on overseas investment decisions of multinational companies along the the Belt and Road" as an example.

In order to save time on binge watching, it's a one-step solution. Output the general requirements to Dou Bao and select 'Write Paper'.

Enter "research field" and "topic" to obtain a framework.

Make a slight adjustment and click on "Generate Document Based on Outline" to directly generate a complete "garbage" and "paper" from introduction to references without missing a word.

The sidebar of WPS has also launched a new feature called "WPS Lingxi Beta", which is integrated with DeepSeek R1 and supports online search. It can directly generate documents for editing.

Doubao writing, DS expansion, WPS formatting, AI one-stop solution

Then, we will paste the paper into WPS and prepare to grade this AI assignment.

As expected, the first issue arose. The text written by AI is too messy when opened in WPS, with incorrect line spacing, first line abbreviation, and font size.

You should know that adjusting the format is like constipation, and it takes a lot of effort and pain to complete the process of excretion. However, wiping the buttocks always fails to clean them thoroughly. In short, every time I try to wipe them, there is always a little bit.

Fortunately, there is no need to arrange new AI. WPS seems to have already introduced new AI layout features to please me, so let's test them out.

We directly opened the "Paper Layout" in "AI Layout" and were surprised to find that many university names appeared in the right column. The preliminary statistics included 700+university templates, and almost all the names could be found. Click to apply the school's prescribed paper format with just one click. Only what you can't think of, there's nothing WPS can't do. If there's no matching format, you can manually input the sample essay layout, wonderful!

Taking the University of International Business and Economics as an example, let's test the layout effect.

Comparing the writing format requirements released by the school, it was found that the first and second level headings, first line indentation, and font size of the main text were indeed changed to be consistent with the requirements.

The reference list has been changed directly from the top to the bottom, and the effect is decent. But there are indeed some minor issues, such as some characters still being gray in color, and previously bolded characters not being removed from bolding, which is not a big problem and is acceptable.

Overall, it is very efficient for formatting, not only can it first eliminate a large number of errors, but it can also customize templates according to the school.

Next, polish the content.

I believe everyone has experienced a similar situation before, when writing a paper, only to realize that the full text has just reached the required word count. Sometimes, word count is not only the word count, but also represents the attitude towards learning.

Here, AI can be used to expand some simple sentences.

We will try sending a simple sentence to DeepSeek to give it a try.

It has been observed that 'WPS AI' also has a polishing function. Just click, saving the effort of "Ctrl+Ctrl V". Not only can there be extensions and abbreviations, but different styles can also be chosen for polishing.

The "more lively" below is indeed quite lively and looks very lively, but it is recommended not to use it in papers!!

From the perspective of effectiveness, quick polishing actually changes the "mean" to the "average value", which plays a role in rapid optimization. Expanding is quite useful, adding a lot of words and saving our lives in critical moments.

Here's another tip, it's best to expand the main body, otherwise it will appear top heavy.

If the above are still minor issues, then the most fatal problem comes - whether the data in the "paper" is stolen or fabricated.

The output 'paper' includes descriptive statistical tables, benchmark regression tables, and even the 'three stars' that I couldn't get even after putting in a lot of effort and effort.

Because the original data cannot be obtained, this part is highly likely to be fabricated and fabricated.

It seems that the most basic data analysis still needs to be done by oneself, and AI can only serve as an auxiliary.

Finally, we have reached the final step, and once we have written the policy recommendations, we have achieved great success!

The long writing in front has exhausted the inspiration. Suddenly, I am a little short of words for this patterned part, and I can't write formulaic words.

This kind of job is perfect for assigning to AI. Taking the "Companion" function in the "WPS AI" toolbar as an example, when clicked, four different roles appear - General, Administrative, Teacher, and Operations. After selecting the function, the next sentence will automatically appear at the cursor position. Although the content of the continuation at the beginning was not satisfactory, with sufficient supplementary content, companion writing is indeed more useful.

WPS AI quickly rewrites non-conforming content

After finishing the entire article, if you read it from scratch, you will always find that some parts are not satisfactory. How to quickly rewrite that part according to the requirements?

You can try WPS AI's "article writing" function

Find "AI Template" in "New" - "Text", and click "Article Writing".

By entering the "article content requirements", as well as the "author role", "target audience", and "required word count", you can easily rewrite the part of the content you want to replace with one click.

If you are still not satisfied after rewriting, you can continue to click "WPS AI" in the toolbar to perform polishing, expansion, and abbreviation operations.

After completing the full text of Easter eggs

I've been busy for a long time, so easy to come up with a complete paper. Before sending it to the teacher, check for duplicates.

No need to work hard to upload documents anymore, WPS members can directly perform "paper plagiarism check" and "AI ghostwriting detection".

Before sending, I was feeling very anxious. Why don't we let the AI hear if our heartbeat is fast at this moment.

But we are not unreasonable either. We can only say that our words are not rude or unreasonable, and we didn't make any mistakes in scolding.

However, sometimes we can't fully believe what AI says, like the nonsense above, just take a look.

Sometimes life is like a small boat sailing in the sea. Whether it is overturned by the waves or successfully reaches the other shore depends on a little bit of luck. Let AI calculate fortune telling.

extremely lucky Hurry up and buy obsidian and turquoise!

Never mind, before buying obsidian, I remembered that I hadn't made the PPT for the classroom presentation yet. I used a dead horse as a living horse doctor and tried generating a PPT using WPS AI documents.

First, confirm if there are any issues with the outline, and then choose a template.

I generated over twenty pages of PPT in a very short amount of time, and I did a little bit of work on it. At least I have the template, so I will make the necessary changes myself as soon as possible!

*The accompanying images in the text are sourced from the internet

Author | AIAA official account: Zhiji

This article was originally published by @ Zhihe on Everyone is a Product Manager. Reproduction without the author's permission is prohibited

Image from Unsplash, based on CC0 protocol

The viewpoint of this article only represents the author himself, and everyone is a product manager. The platform only provides information storage space services

DeepSeek、豆包、WPS AI，谁才是最强AI论文神器？